Skip to content

To Sing the Body Electric

I’ve been privileged enough to be in close contact with 5 people in the last decade as they approached death. For some it was rapid, for others not. For some it was peaceful, for others not. I’ve also had more than my fair share of “too close for comfort” moments for someone of my age. Each time I have been in the presence of death (imminent or threatened) I have been aware of the presence of something else – something wordless and silent. It is the great shock of death: that it is the place where words truly fail us. For a lover of words it is a shock, but still true. Words cannot touch us at that time, cannot reach us, they make no sense. Nor can they ease the shock and awe. For at that moment what comes sharply into focus is not the words “This is it. It’s over” even though they ring through our minds so loudly in the lead up to the final moments. But something else, some quietly insistent thing, pulls us towards the sensual, living being. Some deep awareness that what matters is that living, breathing, pulsing, body. This knowledge is not encoded in impulses in the brain but stored much deeper. It pulses through you, as you struggle to accept that flawed and failing body is all there is. As the body staggers and stumbles towards the end, the world of words seems nothing more than a mirage.

How could I ever have thought that words could save me? There are no words ever invented that could hold what these feelings circle endlessly, terrifyingly, joyously, around. They are loose, free, unconfined and unconstrained feelings. They dip in and out of the depths of despair, soar occasionally to the heights of ecstasy, but mostly bump along the muddy shore looking for a place to rest, a place to recuperate. How could we bear it, how could we bear it if words finally captured all that? We are blessed instead with a quietness that descends: the sound of breathing, of skin stroking skin, of lips as they touch the loved one for the last time, of the world outside carrying on oblivious to the enormity of what is happening. It feels so comfortable and comforting to be freed for that time from the curse of words. There is nothing left to say, all that is over. All that matters is that your body is there with theirs. Towards the very end even direct touch can become unnecessary, unwelcome. All that is left is presence; one body present with another at the end.

For those who walk back into the world, away from that shore, it’s hard to see everyday life as anything but a giant attempt to look away. We are so frightened, we poor little creatures. We dress life up in endless rules and structures and processes. We play out roles. We busy ourselves with all of this “production of self”. What else explains how ridiculous we poor creatures are? We are gifted with this amazing collection of atoms – the human body. And almost immediately we set about destroying its essence. We deny it free expression, we constrain it, we hide it behind job titles and uniforms, we build an imaginary world of abstract ideas in which the body does not matter, only one’s access to knowledge and ideas which then confer status and material wealth dictate one’s quality of life. From the beginning we force it to sit still and cram its head full of these of abstract ideas to prepare it for a life of yet more abstraction. We know its power – we punish it when the rules are broken: hurt it, lock it away, even kill it (and we do this to our own bodies as much as to others). We obsess endlessly on how it ought to look – one generation prizes one look, another something else. The denial of our sensual selves surely explains how we have managed to create such irrational, mad, cruel systems of living. Why we allow ourselves to be so damaged. Why we stand by as others are damaged. Why we damage.

But every now and again, alone in the night, or an opera house, or standing at night watching the sky, I feel it again. The sense that that this body, living here and now, is all that truly matters, and in that knowledge is freedom and the pathway to a less damaged and damaging life. Children know it, they submit to the sensual so much more freely than us. Artists know it, why else would art exist? Sex of course brings us very close to it, albeit briefly and usually mixed up with a whole heap of damaging mind-self nonsense. Music reminds us of it perhaps more immediately than anything else. Our sensual selves constantly circle our abstracted life of the mind looking to creep in and upset our carefully ordered “lives”. We hold them off with our words and ideas, but every visit to that shore is a reminder. In the sensuality of dying we are called to consider the simple sensuality of life. In the sensuality of dying is a reminder to attend to the sensual. Not in some “hedonistic pleasure seeker” way (we label the sensual like that to hide from its importance, its essential truth) but in the simple way we do at that moment. At that moment we are truly alive. Being in the presence of death urges us to be aware, present, open to the sensuality of life. As Walt Whitman reminds us in I Sing the Body Electric:

I have perceiv’d that to be with those I like is enough,
To stop in company with the rest at evening is enough,
To be surrounded by beautiful, curious, breathing, laughing flesh is enough,
To pass among them, or touch any one, or rest my arm ever so lightly round his or her neck for a moment—what is this, then?
I do not ask any more delight—I swim in it, as in a sea.        

There is something in staying close to men and women, and looking on them, and in the contact and odor of them, that pleases the soul well;
All things please the soul—but these please the soul well.

Be Patient, Let Yourself Heal

When things are shaky and nothing is working, we might realize that we are on the verge of something. We might realize that this is a very vulnerable and tender place, and that tenderness can go either way. We can shut down and feel resentful or we can touch in on that throbbing quality.

Pema Chodron “When Things Fall Apart”

“Life” seems to be putting itself back together again very quickly at the moment. After the strangeness of summer, the strangeness of “normality”. But in this “normal living” the enormity of the changes this summer has wrought in me is becoming ever more apparent.

A mantra ran through my head in those days – be patient, let yourself heal. I wondered at the time if the shock of what happened was what allowed me to reclaim that essential idea – be patient, let yourself heal. It felt really familiar. Yet when I think of the time before the summer I was very far removed from that idea. I did not accept I was ill. The concept of patience had little place in my “busy” life. I was running so fast away from my problems and challenges that I had lost sight of them. My distress, my suffering, it seemed to me then, was just part of my failure to “cope”.

Living with something like MS does bring one very close to the abyss more regularly than might otherwise have been the case. But the human mind is very good at not seeing what it does not wish to see. I had been very good at averting my eyes on the numerous occasions the abyss loomed these last 20 some years of living with MS. This summer however I tumbled over the edge of my abyss. This summer there was no averting the eyes possible, as I plummeted down that black hole. I had to look at the things I was most afraid of, the things that haunted me, the things I was sure I could not deal with. And in that moment, I knew I could. Coping might mean choosing the manner and moment of my death, or allowing the universe to do that for me, or living through (not in spite of) pain, suffering, things falling apart. But coping was possible. This didn’t happen in some easy way, or as a blinding moment of revelation. It did not feel special even, this realisation. It just felt, as Pema Chodron puts it, like a turning and touching something vulnerable.

There is something raw in me now that was not there before, something exposed and vulnerable, like a pulsating living heart exposed on an operating table. Yet it is not uncomfortable, but rather oddly calming and reassuring, this rawness. I’ve been wondering about it especially these last few days as life resumed its fairly hectic pace once again. For what I have realised is that it’s what is keeping me focussed on my mantra “Be patient – let yourself heal”. At all sorts of odd and not so odd moments I feel that rawness sweep over me as I suddenly remember the summer, and feel the ghosts of my fears and distress. I find myself “back there” but back there in a different way. I am no longer afraid to be afraid. I am happy to be raw, to be vulnerable. It reminds me of my strength. It reminds me to care for myself. It reminds me of the inevitability of pain and suffering and the possibility of facing that with calmness. I allow myself to feel vulnerable, to feel scared, but I am no longer swept away by that. I am no longer so distressed that I shut it down.

Inside every one of us, from the moment we are born, is that rawness, like some vulnerable creature. But as we grow up too often we are taught not to see the vulnerable creature inside. To be grown up means not to be vulnerable. To be grown up means to “cope”. So much effort goes into hiding from the vulnerable creature, because it reminds us of the abyss and all the scary things in there we do not want to see.

The rawness I feel now is simply the recognition of my vulnerable creature. She’s not a stranger, she’s always been there, patiently waiting for me to acknowledge her so that together we might begin to heal. Heal not in some simple sense of “make it all better”, rather heal in one of its other definitions – to make whole again. She reminds me gently but firmly “Be patient – let yourself heal”.

Normal life is resuming – by which I principally mean there is more to do each day than there is day to do it in. But my vulnerable creature reminds me to be ok with that, to be gentle on myself for not being superhuman, and to care for myself in a crazy world that would otherwise happily watch me fall apart rather than try to heal itself. I can’t heal the world, but I can heal me. Patiently.

Towanda's Window

Fangirling Is Resistance

Lou's Story

Our journey with cancer

Vanessa's War

The wartime memoirs of Lady Vanessa Montague

Equality by lot

The blog of the Kleroterians

Citizen Participation Network

Connecting Research, Policy and Practice on Participatory Democracy

The Eyes Have It

an appreciation

drkategranger

In memory of an inspiring young doctor who mused about life & death through her terminal cancer illness

criticaldispatches.com/

Follow me on Twitter and Instagram @RichyDispatch

opera, innit?

a good Tito/mezzo guide

atrophiedmind

140 characters aren't enough for this stuff...

Bullet Proof Cardie

A doctor in recovery writes...........

Leisurely Seeking Doctorate

A fifty-something American explores doing a PhD in the UK — and then turns 60 and does it

@katetowsey

Content Strategy - Delivery - User Research

Swimming in Stormy Weather

Fieldnotes from the World of MS, White Shirts & Opera

Content At Large

Notes from the front: Content strategy, development and dissemination ideas from champions and leaders in the field

NeuroBollocks

Debunking pseudo-neuroscience so you don't have to

What I did on my holidays

A week in Ireland. Alone

Bella Caledonia

it's time to get above ourselves

%d bloggers like this: